Showing posts with label Human Trafficking. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Human Trafficking. Show all posts

Thursday, February 4, 2016

Finally - Absolute Must-Read Guides to US Foreign Corrupt Practices Act for human and labor rights activists

As anyone who has ever worked on an investigation under the US Foreign Corrupt Practices Act is aware (For guidance, see the US Department of Justice web guide at http://www.justice.gov/criminal-fraud/fcpa-guidance), the FCPA is a great tool enabling companies and enforcers to identify, prevent and remedy bribery of foreign government officials in exchange for business advantage.  

It's not just the expansive extraterritorial jurisdiction; the availability of both civil and criminal penalties (including fines and jail sentences); and strong enforcement by US authorities in the US Department of Justice and the Securities and Exchange Commission.  It is also the immense web of compliance practices and risk assessments that have developed over time both within companies and in company networks.  This compliance web includes internal audits; robust compliance teams; due diligence of third parties; special contract provisions making bribery of a foreign official an event allowing termination of the contract; electronic filtering of transactions; multiple trainings and compliance manuals; and global lists of companies and individuals with government or criminal ties  The thoroughness and complexity of this web is mind boggling.

On the other hand, as anyone who works in human and labor rights or represents migrant workers and/or victims of human trafficking knows, human trafficking and migrant smuggling cannot occur without the knowledge and complicity of certain government officials - the obvious suspected linking factor being bribery and corruption.

In recent years, the NGO Vérité has started issuing reports and studies drawing the link between human trafficking and exploitation on the one hand and bribery and corruption on the other (See Vérité's 2013 White Paper Corruption & Labor Trafficking in Global Supply Chains here:  http://www.verite.org/sites/default/files/images/WhitePaperCorruptionLaborTrafficking.pdf).  In 2013, global anti corruption NGO Transparency International highlighted the role bribes paid to building inspectors played in fires and building collapses that killed hundreds of workers in disasters like the one that occurred at Rana Plaza in Bangladesh (See Transparency International, "In Bangladesh, corruption kills hundreds," April 26, 2013, http://www.transparency.org/news/feature/in_bangladesh_corruption_kills_hundreds).

At long last, the NGOs Liberty Asia (libertyasia.org) and The Freedom Fund (freedomfund.org) have produced two absolute must-read clear language guides to the FCPA for human rights advocates.  The first is a 16-page briefing paper Modern Slavery and Corruption (http://freedomfund.org/wp-content/uploads/Liberty-Asia-Corruption-Briefing-Paper-FINAL-FOR-EMAIL.pdf) providing a thumbnail sketch of the FCPA and clearly highlighting the points at which bribery plays a role in the human trafficking process.  Some of these points include pressure to use labor brokers related to government officials (a kickback or direct benefit scheme); provision of excessive and extravagant gifts to officials responsible for issuing permits and licenses (a practice expressly prohibited under the FCPA); bribes to officials at border checkpoints to allow trafficked persons to pass through without scrutiny; bribes to police and inspectors to ignore mistreatment of workers or workplace violations.  These and other elements of corruption are highlighted in a case study of a hypothetical victim of human trafficking in this excellent and poignant briefing paper.

Less concise but equally useful is the 148-page legal guide Modern Slavery and Corruption- Legal Analysis of Relevant Laws and Their Application (http://freedomfund.org/wp-content/uploads/Liberty-Asia-Corruption-Legal-Analysis-FINAL-FOR-EMAIL.pdf).  This excellent legal guide punctuates each well-documented explanation of FCPA statutory law with a takeaway message that is easily digestible by the human rights activist.  For example, on the subject of 3rd party liability, the guide notes, "[T]he use of labor recruiters to secure seasonal labor and low-skilled labor, as well as the use of products whose supply chain is known to utilize human trafficking, are all warning signs that might give rise to FCPA liability if companies do not conduct proper due diligence."  

The legal guide also explains the UK Bribery Act (which prohibits bribery of private company officials as well as foreign government officials), the US Trafficking Victims Protection Act and other relevant legislation.  Importantly, the guide lends visibility into corporate compliance programs and culture (see p. 24 et seq.) - critical elements in the enforcement of legal norms prohibiting bribery, money laundering, financing of terrorism and other types of corporate and legal risk.

Putting an end to corruption, human trafficking and abuse of migrant workers is a 2-way street.  CSR and Corporate Compliance departments within companies must talk to each other; corporate compliance professionals must communicate norms and opportunities to human rights advocates; and human rights advocates must sensitize corporate compliance professionals about compliance risks inherent in human trafficking and other human and labor rights abuses.

In sum, Read these manuals!  They are great - actually awesome - resources.

Tuesday, May 26, 2015

Voice and Transparency in Aaronson's May 2015 paper "New Ideas to Empower US and European Workers in TTIP"

Earlier this year I had the opportunity to participate in an exciting survey administered by Susan Aaronson of the George Washington University Elliott School on how best to incorporate worker rights in the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP), a free trade agreement being negotiated between the United States and the European Union.  One of Dr. Aaronson's primary projects is Make Trade Policy More Trusted, Transparent and Accountable at the GWU Institute for International Economic Policy.  Participating in the survey gave me and the other 22 respondents a chance to get some of our ideas and recommendations into trade and labor policy discussions while TTIP negotiations are ongoing.  Some of the ideas I had that made it into the final paper were (1) inclusion of provisions to address human trafficking; and (2) emphasis on utilization of creative international cooperation mechanisms like the Joint Public Advisory Committee which has been an innovative and effective mechanism for public involvement in the North American Commission of Environmental Cooperation.

Susan Aaronson's resulting paper Working by Design New Ideas to Empower US and European Workers in TTIP was released at a joint ILO-GWU conference held in Washington, DC on May 14, 2015.  In addition to the findings and recommendations resulting from the survey, the paper captures some of the misgivings many have about the possible negative impacts the TTIP could have on workers' rights, particularly on strong labor and social welfare protections in most European Union member states.  The paper also captures key differences in the US and EU approaches to labor rights in free trade agreements (See p. 7).

One of the most compelling recommendations from the survey is that labor, human and social welfare rights should be considered and incorporated throughout the text of the US-EU free trade agreement (instead of in just a single chapter) as a way to advance labor rights and increase employment (See pp. 12, 21).  Aaronson points to a proposed "regulatory coherence" chapter that could have a negative impact on worker rights as its aim is to "ensure that domestic regulations, such as environmental regulations, health and safety standards or workplace regulations do not distort trade" (p. 13).  She cites a 2015 ETUI policy brief written by Aida Ponce titled TTIP:  fast track to deregulation and lower health and safety protection for EU workers as an example of how a US-EU free trade agreement regulatory coherence chapter might lower workplace standards in the EU.  Two other proposed chapters that could have a negative impact on worker rights are the proposed services and investment chapters.

The paper also includes some other survey recommendations of note such as:
  • Improvements to the labor dispute process under TTIP (p. 22); 
  • Periodic (every 5 years) reporting on the TTIP's impact on the realization of ILO core labor rights (p. 23);
  • Specific exclusion of minimum or living wage laws, collective bargaining agreements, public procurement standards and public health and welfare regulations from the Investor-State Dispute provisions (p. 21);
  • Establishment of an independent Secretariat to resolve disputes, issue reports, conduct research and engage in innovative projects to promote worker rights (p. 23); and
  • Improved transparency in the TTIP negotiation process to allow the public to better understand how the agreement will expand employment and protect labor rights (p. 24).
The Working by Design paper takes a hopeful stance on ways the TTIP might be used to improve the lives in hundreds of millions of workers in the U.S. and Europe.  Nevertheless, I am left wondering if strong worker and social protections in almost every EU member state might be interpreted as trade distortions under a less than artfully crafted US-EU free trade agreement, leading to erosion rather than improvement of standards.

Finally, while I enjoyed the ILO-GWU conference (and picked up some useful tidbits of updated information) where the Working by Design paper was released, I wonder if the traditional conference format of 15-minute speeches and audience questions is the best way to come up with genuinely creative ideas.  In over 15 years of speaking at and attending international and comparative labor and employment conferences, only once have I attended an event that had an alternative format which captured and improved upon the ideas of the participants - the First Hispanic Forum on a Safe and Healthy Environment held in Orlando in 2003.  At the First Hispanic Forum on a Safe and Healthy Environment, participants were divided into 3 groups where we worked with facilitators to discuss and develop our ideas into a final set of recommendations which were then merged together in a single document on the final day of the Forum.  Maybe the next step in the Working for All work stream should be the First Global Forum on New Ideas and Innovative Strategies to Enhance Economic and Social Benefits in Trade Agreements - where the audience teaches the speakers rather than the other way around.