Showing posts with label 1998 ILO Declaration. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 1998 ILO Declaration. Show all posts

Saturday, February 6, 2021

Panel of Experts releases significant report analyzing Freedom of Association obligations in EU-Korea Free Trade Agreement


The World Cup for International Labor Lawyers came early this year with the release of the Report of the Panel of Experts analyzing labor obligations under the EU-Korea Free Trade Agreement in January. This report is the most significant legal development in the field of Trade and Labor Provisions since June 2017, when an Arbitral Panel released its report analyzing labor obligations under the CAFTA-DR in Guatemala. 

For the "Tik Tok" version of the Panel's report, see my piece in the
ABA's International Labor and Employment Law Committee Newsletter, Panel of Experts Issues Report on Labor Issues Raised under EU-Korea FTA. 

For a more in-depth discussion of the Panel's legal
analysis of the concept of Freedom of Assocation, see Tonia Novitz's excellent February 4 Oxford Human Rights Hub post, Asserting Jurisdiction to Assess Compliance with 'Multilateral labour standards and agreements' - The EU-Korea FTA Panel Decision.

And, for a thought-provoking analysis of the Report of the Panel of Experts in the EU-Korea case, check out Desiree LeClerqc's thoughtful post in the International Law and Economic Policy Blog, The Panel Report under the EU-Korea Trade Agreement Concerning Labor Practices: What are the Purposes of Trade Agreements as they Relate to the ILO's Fundamental Labor Rights? In this piece, LeClerqc takes on the issue of coherence in the interpretation and analysis of fundamental labor rights, the 1998 ILO Declaration, and ILO Conventions. 

Labor and Trade Lawyers are going to be discussing and comparing the EU-Korea and the CAFTA-DR Guatemala labor reports for years to come. At the heart of this debate is the fundamental role of workers in the global economy - rights and trade, who determines the substance and implementation of those rights ... a very interesting era to be working on these issues.


Friday, February 2, 2018

New article assesses FTA labor provisions from gender perspective

My forthcoming article in the Comparative Labor Law & Policy Journal assesses labor provisions in US and Canadian free trade agreements both generally and from a gender perspective. See SSRN for a link to the article:  https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3056990. See this IntLawGrrls piece for a sketch of the main arguments and points made in the article.

Policy makers and advocates in both countries have made great strides in the past quarter century since NAFTA was negotiated, but much work remains to be done.  The key to progress has been creative advocacy efforts by trade unions and workers' human rights advocates on the one hand and intelligent, creative, and responsive problem solving methods by policy makers.

The article shows how both advocates and policy makers have overcome definitional and procedural shortcomings in FTA labor provisions to make them useful tools for worker rights advocacy.  It also highlights weaknesses and shortcomings in the texts of FTA labor provisions that must be addressed to make them truly transformational.

Sunday, July 23, 2017

U.S. negotiation objectives for New NAFTA: Labor no longer separate, but still unequal

This piece was simultaneously posted on the HuffPost.

***

Publicly, American workers are the focus of the much-touted renegotiation of NAFTA announced by USTR in May. The first round of negotiations begins on August 16, 2017. USTR’s NAFTA negotiation objectives, released on July 17th, place the American worker front and center, observing that trade deficits and factory closures created by NAFTA have left American workers economically stranded. Such bold rhetoric might lead observers to believe that the administration’s negotiation objectives for labor provisions in NAFTA will be equally bold. Sadly, this is not the case.

NAFTA’s 1994 labor side agreement – the North American Agreement on Labor Cooperation or NAALC – has been criticized for (1) inadequate dispute resolution mechanisms; (2) not including the core labor standards of Freedom of Association, Right to Collective Bargaining and Right to Strike in NAALC’s full panoply of dispute resolution mechanisms; (3) setting a benchmark for enforcement of existing national laws rather than international labor standards; and (4) failing to result in meaningful change in workers’ lives in North America.

Criticism of the NAALC and imperfect implementation and application by policy makers have obfuscated the agreement’s strengths. NAALC is the only international labor agreement that is fully binding and readily enforceable on the United States. Over 25% of NAALC petitions filed since 1995 have been filed with Mexico about ineffectual enforcement of labor laws in the United States. NAALC’s definition of labor law covers 11 labor principles and is arguably broader than the definition in subsequent U.S. FTAs. In addition to covering minimum wage standards, occupational safety and health and the core labor standards outlined in the 1998 ILO Declaration on Fundamental Rights at Work, NAALC covers compensation for workplace injuries and equal labor protection for migrant workers. Surprisingly, NAALC’s gender protections are stronger than those in CAFTA-DR, which does not extend its dispute resolution provisions to the elimination of workplace discrimination and guarantee of equal pay for women and men in Central America. Finally, NAALC’s public communication process allowing members of civil society to file petitions alleging a member state has failed to effectively enforce labor laws has been duplicated in every subsequent U.S. FTA since.

Labor advocates have criticized NAALC on the “Separate and Unequal” standard, arguing that workers are not afforded the same mechanisms and remedies afforded to businesses and other member states under NAFTA’s business-to-state and state-to-state international arbitration procedures. Instead, NAALC provides for a public petition process (leading to a public report and government discussions); the possibility of the establishment of an Evaluative Committee of Experts (ECE) to issue a neutral report analyzing subjects raised in petitions; and finally, the potential for international arbitration and limited trade sanctions.

Following the pattern of every U.S. FTA negotiated since the 2000 U.S.-Jordan FTA, USTR’s current proposal is that labor provisions will be benchmarked to international labor standards, brought into the core NAFTA text, and subject to the same government-to-government arbitration mechanisms as other NAFTA disputes. This may seem like an advancement intellectually. In practice, realization of the fantasy of using international trade arbitration to address issues raised under FTA labor provisions has left much to be desired. On June 26, 2017, it was announced that the U.S. lost to Guatemala in the very first international trade arbitration resulting from a petition arguing that Guatemala failed to comply with its labor obligations under CAFTA-DR. First filed in April 2008, the Guatemala CAFTA-DR labor petition took over 9 years to wend its way to this ignominious conclusion.

NAALC also suffers from the Separate and Unequal standard when it comes to treatment of different labor principles under its dispute resolution mechanisms. Not all 11 labor principles are subject to the fully panoply of dispute resolution under the NAALC. A NAALC arbitral panel can only be requested in the case of petitions relating to occupational safety and health, child labor or minimum wage standards.

This shortcoming is not addressed in USTR’s 2017 proposal. In its NAFTA renegotiation objectives, USTR vows to “[e]stablish rules that will ensure that NAFTA countries do not fail to effectively enforce their labor laws implementing internationally recognized core labor standards and acceptable conditions of work with respect to minimum wages, hours of work, and occupational safety and health laws.” USTR’s proposal actually narrows the scope of dispute resolution under New NAFTA by not including child labor as one of the listed subjects eligible for international arbitration.

In fact, USTR’s NAFTA re-renegotiation objectives set a tougher standard for proving a violation of labor obligations in international arbitration than that set in the NAALC. Under NAALC, a case may be subject to arbitration if a member state’s failure to effectively enforce labor laws is “trade-related.” The proposed standard in the renegotiation objectives is failure to effectively enforce “through a sustained or recurring course of action or inaction, in a manner affecting trade or investment between the parties.” This is similar to the standard set in CAFTA-DR – which turned out to be insurmountable for USTR in the CAFTA-DR Guatemala labor arbitration case - not to mention for trade unions, civil society groups and workers of limited means.

It is not just that USTR’s labor-related NAFTA renegotiation goals fail to address NAALC’s most obvious flaws, eliminate some of NAALC’s positive attributes and duplicate past labor-related trade negotiation objectives. New NAFTA will never address serious labor market policy failures by the U.S. and its North American neighbors to address job loss and economic decline that result not only from free trade but technological and economic change. New NAFTA is just Old NAFTA in new clothes.

Like it or not, the current administration must recognize that Zero Sum We Win-You Lose strategies will not heal what ails the American workforce. Negotiation of a New NAFTA that better serves America’s workers requires a truly bold approach, not regurgitation of the same old approaches. It should improve NAFTA’s labor standards and dispute resolution mechanisms and incorporate measures that empower Mexico, Canada and the U.S. to engage in serious regional employment policy development and human and physical infrastructure investment. It means that the U.S. must cooperate with Canada and Mexico to find ways to improve educational and labor market outcomes on both sides of both borders. It also means looking to bold ideas like those expressed in Stephen Zamora’s 2008 article A Proposed North American Regional Development Fund: The Next Phase of American Integration under NAFTA.

Some concrete proposals to improve the negotiation objectives for the New NAFTA include:

  • Exploration of the idea of incorporating the Evaluative Committee of Experts process in the dispute resolution mechanism as an intermediate step on the way to arbitration in order to provide arbitrators with a common factual and labor standards basis for analyzing the facts in arbitral proceedings;
  • Incorporation of the 2016 Trilateral M.O.U. Promoting Women’s Entrepreneurship and the Growth of Women-Owned Enterprises in North America into NAFTA’s text and expansion of the M.O.U. to promote women’s empowerment in the workplace and society as outlined in the 2012 US-Mexico M.O.U. on Women’s Economic Empowerment;
  • Removal of the insurmountable standard of proving a country has failed to effectively enforce labor law “through a sustained or recurring course of action or inaction, in a manner affecting trade or investment between the parties” from the New NAFTA negotiation proposal;
  • Expansion of NAFTA’s dispute resolution and arbitral provisions to cover all labor standards covered by the definition of labor law, including: collective labor rights; the elimination of workplace discrimination and guarantee of equal pay for equal work for women and men; elimination of forced labor; and elimination of child labor;
  • Explicit retention of compensation for workplace injuries in the list of labor laws covered by NAFTA;
  • Strengthening of cooperative mechanisms in NAFTA to allow for the development of a North American Employment Policy and Jobs Strategy similar to the European Employment Strategy – including the participation of large and small employers, trade unions, women’s rights groups and other members of civil society;
  • Retention of the labor principle requiring equal treatment for migrant workers; and
  • Development of a North American Investment Fund to help employers and workers adapt to economic and labor market changes caused by free trade as well as technological and economic change.
Other proposals to consider that are currently outside the U.S. trade policy development framework include:

  • Requirement that the U.S. conduct a Human Rights Impact Assessment (HRIA) and Women’s Rights Impact Assessment (WRIA) of New NAFTA before it is implemented, in addition to the labor and environmental studies already required by Congress; and
  • Incorporation of human rights and rule of law provisions in the New NAFTA.

These proposals do not even capture the kind of bold rethinking that needs to be done with respect to renegotiation of NAFTA. Clearly, the administration and we as a country and region are not “there” yet.

Thursday, September 29, 2016

Colombia: Violence against trade unionists impacts OECD bid, trade relations with U.S.

My two recent pieces on labor issues in Colombia  highlight how important effective protection of freedom of association and the right to collective bargaining are to a country's participation in the global community.

The first piece in The International Employment Lawyer USA - Department of Labor Accepts First Labor Petition Under US-Colombia Trade Promotion Agreement (Fall 2016) discusses the recent labor petition filed by Colombian trade unions and the AFL-CIO under the U.S.-Colombia free trade agreement.  At issue is whether or not the Government of Colombia has fully complied with labor-related commitments in the FTA and a 2011 Labor Rights Action Plan outlining a number of pre-conditions to be met by Colombia before the FTA went into effect.  If Colombia cannot effectively protect trade unionists from murder and violence, it risks losing U.S. trade benefits.

The second piece in IntLawGrrls Violence against trade unionists, application of labor laws at issue in Colombia’s bid for OECD membership (September 2016) discusses labor and social protection issues related to Colombia's bid to become a member of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD).  The OECD's 2016 report on labor and social protection in Colombia highlights the same issues raised by Colombian and U.S. trade unions - including failure to protect trade unionists from violence - as areas of improvement to be addressed before Colombia can joint the club of elite governments in the OECD.  If Colombia cannot find a way to improve Rule of Law and protect trade unionists from murder and threats of violence, it may fail in its bid to join the OECD.

Now that Colombia has signed a Peace Agreement with the FARC, it will be interesting to see whether efforts on an international level and within Colombia will lead to meaningful change for Colombian workers.

Sunday, January 31, 2016

Gender Analysis of 2015 CAFTA‐DR Report on and Action Plan for Honduras: Public Comment to USDOL National Advisory Committee

The USDOL National Advisory Committee for Labor Provisions of US Free Trade Agreements provides the public with a great venue for comments on labor provisions of US free trade agreements - as well as a forum for learning the most up to date information about US implementation of FTA labor provisions.

The next meeting is from 9:30 am to 4:30 pm on Tuesday, February 2 in Washington, DC.

I've expanded my initial gender analysis of USDOL's CAFTA-DR report on and action plan for labor standards in Honduras to include (1) a discussion of the narrow interpretation of the definition of "labor law" to exclude gender and discrimination issues from the scope of CAFTA-DR's labor chapter; (2) a recommendation that a supplemental report be issued and action plan be developed on workplace gender issues in Honduras; and (3) a new References and Resources section with background information on the Honduras petition and report, gender and trade and gender sensitive approaches to OSHA and general workplace inspections.

One great new development in USDOL's implementation of FTA labor provisions is making public a complete Spanish translation of its 143-page February 2015 report on Honduras.

Check out my academia.edu site to read my full comment to USDOL's National Advisory Committee here:  Gender Analysis of 2015 CAFTA-DR Report on and Action Plan for Honduras:  Public Comment to USDOL National Advisory Committee.

I'm looking forward to seeing whether and how USDOL and the NAC respond to my public comment.

Monday, January 18, 2016

USDOL failure to address sex discrimination claims in CAFTA-DR Honduras Report and Action Plan puzzles, disappoints

In early 2015, the U.S. Department of Labor issued its much-anticipated report on trade unions' public submission contending that the Government of Honduras failed to set high labor standards and effectively enforce existing labor laws.  The 143-page report confirmed petitioners' claims, observing that some progress was made during the 3 years since the petition was originally filed but that the Honduran Ministry of Labor (Secretaría de Trabajo y Seguridad Social - STSS) continues to fall short in responding to complaints, conducting inspections and remediating workplace violations.  The report made 7 recommendations for improvement of STSS labor inspections including imposing sanctions for labor law violations, compelling access to worksites, compelling employer compliance with remediation orders and improving enforcement of laws related to freedom of association, collective bargaining and child labor.

Notably absent from USDOL's report was any reference to or acknowledgement of claims of systemic sex discrimination in the Honduran garment sector outlined by petitioners in their 2012 public submission.  Petitioners highlighted the discriminatory nature of Honduras' industry-based minimum wage setting mechanism which set wages significantly lower in the predominantly female garment sector than in other manufacturing sectors (p. 4) and pointed to NGO reports of high levels of mistreatment of women workers in the form of verbal abuse, shoving, punching, denial of meal breaks, sexual harassment, sexual assault, sex-motivated dismissals and pregnancy discrimination (p. 5).

A critical element of petitioners' overall argument in the submission was that discriminatory low wages paid in the garment sector directly affects trade between the U.S. and Honduras (p. 5), thereby violating Honduras' commitment under CAFTA-DR Article 16.1(1) to strive to set high labor standards in conformity with the 1998 ILO Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rightsat Work and its Follow-Up.

Despite early criticism that USDOL's report was incomplete (See Mateo Crossa, "Honduras: US Government Fails to Act to Prevent Labor Rights Violations," The Americas Blog, CEPR, March 19, 2015), the Labor Rights Monitoring and Action Plan signed by the labor ministers of the U.S. and Honduras on December 9, 2015 fails to include specific measures to address the problem of workplace sex discrimination in Honduras.  Like the February 2015 report, the Monitoring and Action Plan (MAP) does not contain a single word, commitment or timeline related to addressing the issue of sex discrimination, pay equity or sexual harassment in labor law enforcement, workplace inspections or training for STSS personnel.

USDOL's silence on the issue of sex discrimination in the Honduran garment sector and other industries is puzzling in light of recent reports and actions it has taken in response to submissions filed under the CAFTA-DR and other U.S. free trade agreements.  Since 2009, the Obama Administration has pressed its trading partners not only to improve enforcement of existing labor laws but to achieve a higher standard by passing laws that give life to fundamental labor standards in the ILO Declaration.  Examples include issuing a report exhorting the Government of Bahrain to pass a law prohibiting discrimination based on religion and other grounds; commissioning a series of studies on how to identify indicators of forced labor and slavery in the modern era; and designating funds to eradicate child labor in the Dominican Republic.  Any or all of these responses would have been appropriate in response to the sex discrimination claims raised in the Honduran labor petition under CAFTA-DR - and in fact could form the basis of a work plan to address workplace sex discrimination in Honduras.

By ignoring claims of sex discrimination in its report and action plan in response to the Honduras CAFTA-DR petition, USDOL has demonstrated that it is out of sync with the rest of the international community. The United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) acknowledged as early as 2004 that gender equality is a universal goal and that trade can have important positive and negative implications for women - recommending in its seminal note Trade and Gender:  Opportunities, Challenges and Policy Dimension that women's concerns and role in the economy should be considered in the development of trade policy.  As discussed in the 2002 United Nations guide Gender Mainstreaming An Overview, gender mainstreaming has been a part of international policy making for the last two decades.  Even the World Bank came out in support of workplace childcare facilities because it is good for women's labor force participation, as discussed in Markus Goldstein's September 2013 piece "Building the evidence based roadmap for women's economic empowerment" in the World Bank's Development Impact blog.

The essence of the concept of gender mainstreaming is that issues affecting women in particular must be addressed and incorporated into international policy making.  "Mainstreaming should situate gender equality issues at the centre of analyses and policy decisions, medium-term plans, programme budgets, and institutional structures and processes" (UN 2002, pp. v-vi).  The UN emphasizes that attention to gender issues must be explicit and systematic (p. vi).

In the case of the USDOL report on and action plan for improved workplace law enforcement in Honduras, it is not enough to simply expect that enhanced protections for trade unions and improved labor inspection methods and follow-through in general will address the particular issues faced by working women in Honduras. USDOL and the Obama Administration must explicitly account for and respond to working women's issues in Honduras.

In my mind, there was always a question whether USDOL would embrace the concept of equal pay for equal value implicit in petitioners' argument.  U.S. law recognizes the concept of equal pay for equal or similar work under the 1963 Equal Pay Act, but does not go as far as Canadian law, which recognizes the concept of equal pay for work of equal value - where the work being performed in a predominantly female sector is different but of equal value to work performed in a predominantly male sector (as explained in this November 2015 Ontario Equal Pay website).

What can USDOL do to remedy the situation?

The important question for USDOL, Honduran trade unions and women's rights advocates and their international allies is What now?

USDOL has a number of tools at its disposal to address the big gender gap left by its report on labor law standards and enforcement in Honduras and the resulting Action Plan.

  • Work with Central American women's advocacy groups and trade unions along with the Labor Affairs Council established under Article 16.4 of the CAFTA-DR to develop a Model Code to Eliminate Sex Discrimination, Violence Against Women and Unequal Pay in Central American workplaces.  A 2013 study produced by COVERCO (Guatemala) and other groups in Central America observed that the inequitable minimum wage setting mechanism present in Honduras is present in all of the Central American nations - contributing to overall poverty and lack of well being in these nations.
  • Provide technical support and funding for workplace childcare initiatives such as that agreed to by Honduran employers and trade unions in the 2014 Tripartite Agreement on Employment in the Maquila Sector.  In addition to setting forth a schedule for periodic wage increases, the agreement commits employers to establish workplace child care centers on a pilot basis - a pilot that has yet to be launched, no doubt due to lack of support and funding.
  • Work with women's rights groups, trade unions and international experts to develop best practices for a gendered approach to workplace inspections to identify unequal pay, sex discrimination in promotion and sexual harassment and violence.
  • Address USDOL's own shortcomings in addressing gender issues in labor petitions filed under trade agreements by developing and implementing a policy that mainstreams gender in its day-to-day activities, investigations and reports.
  • Work with the U.S. Department of State, its Central American counterparts, Central American Women's Rights Commissions, trade unions and women's civil society groups in Central America to negotiate a binding Memorandum of Understanding on Women's Rights and Economic Empowerment covering the entire CAFTA-DR region.
What can women's groups and trade unions do to remedy the situation?

Women's advocacy groups, trade unions and their allies have tools and options at their disposal as well.  Among others, these include:
  • Work through existing networks of women's rights groups and trade unions in Central America to file a region-wide sex-discrimination petition under CAFTA-DR Chapter 16 to challenge unfair wage setting mechanisms and inadequate protections against workplace sex discrimination and workplace violence.  The problem with the 2011 Honduras CAFTA-DR petition was that gender issues were buried among over 25 different instances of failure to enforce labor laws in several sectors of the economy.  Focusing solely on sex discrimination will ensure that the subject will not be ignored.
  • Go to Canada.  The United States is not the only actor in the global trade arena with a mechanism for filing claims that a country is not complying with internationally recognized labor standards.  Not only does Canada have more advanced pay equity laws than the U.S., its Labor Cooperation Agreement with Honduras specifically requires Honduras to ensure that its labor law and practices embody and provide protection for the elimination of discrimination with respect to employment occupation.  Under CAFTA-DR, member states are only obligated to "strive to ensure" their labor laws comport with the 1998 ILO Declaration.
It is not fair for working women in Honduras to have to "resubmit" their petition for equal treatment under Honduran labor law.  This was already part of the 2011 petition.  Honduran women - like all women throughout the world - know that if they don't do it, who will?  It is only with constant and sustained pressure that their voices will be truly heard.